Trooping Funnel vs Clouded Funnel vs Livid Pinkgill
From October to December the leaf litter fills with large pale mushrooms growing in rings: the edible Trooping Funnel, the Clouded Funnel that makes many people ill, and occasionally the seriously poisonous Livid Pinkgill. All three are big, pale and fleshy, so shape, stem and spore print matter more than size.
The test that decides it
A tall, cream-buff funnel with a pointed boss in the middle, a stem taller than the cap is wide and a white spore print is the Trooping Funnel. A grey, clouded cap on a stocky club-shaped stem is the Clouded Funnel: leave it. Any large pale mushroom whose gills are yellowish or pink, or whose spore print is pink, may be the Livid Pinkgill and must never be eaten.

Trooping Funnel
Infundibulicybe geotropa
- Cream to pale buff, deeply funnelled
- A pointed boss in the centre, even when old
- Tall stem, often longer than the cap is wide
- White spore print
Full species guide →

Clouded Funnel
Clitocybe nebularis
- Grey to grey-brown cap with a pale clouded bloom
- No pointed boss; flat or only shallowly dished
- Stocky, club-shaped stem
- Cream spore print; upsets many people even when cooked
Full species guide →

Livid Pinkgill
Entoloma sinuatum
- Pale grey to ivory cap, not funnelled
- Gills yellowish when young, turning salmon pink
- Pink spore print
- Mealy smell; causes severe, sometimes hospitalising poisoning
Feature by feature
| Feature | Trooping Funnel | Clouded Funnel | Livid Pinkgill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cap colour | Cream to pale buff or tan | Grey to grey-brown with a whitish bloom | Pale grey to ivory, often silky |
| Cap shape | Deep funnel with a pointed central boss | Convex to flat or shallowly dished, no boss | Convex to flat, wavy, not funnelled |
| Gills | Cream, crowded, running well down the stem | Cream, crowded, slightly running down the stem | Yellowish, then salmon pink, not running down the stem |
| Stem | Tall and fibrous, often longer than the cap is wide | Short, stout and club-shaped | Stout, white, fibrous |
| Spore print | White | Cream | Pink |
| Smell | Faintly sweet, of almonds or hay | Strong, sweetish, unpleasant when old | Mealy, like flour or cucumber |
Never eat a wild mushroom on the strength of a website alone. Some deadly species look very like good edibles. Check every feature, and get an expert opinion if there is any doubt at all.
Read the full foraging safety guidance.
Common questions
- Why is the Clouded Funnel listed as poisonous when people used to eat it?
- Older books list it as edible, but it causes vomiting and stomach pain in a significant share of people even when well cooked, and there is no way to know in advance who will react. Most UK guides now treat it as poisonous.
- Is a spore print really necessary for such a big mushroom?
- Yes. The spore print is the quickest way to rule out the Livid Pinkgill, whose pink print is unlike either funnel. Leave a cap gills-down on white and dark paper overnight.
- Do both funnels grow in rings?
- Both regularly form large rings and lines in woodland litter, often in the same wood in the same week, so finding a ring tells you nothing about which one you have.
Checked against
- Wild Food UK: Clouded Funnel - listed as poisonous for gastric upsets
- Field Mycologist: Clitocybe nebularis - habitat, season and Livid Pinkgill confusion
- Foraging Course Company: Clouded agaric - lookalikes
- Index Fungorum / Species Fungorum current names