← All lookalike guides

The Funnel vs Fool's Funnel vs Tawny Funnel

Funnel-shaped mushrooms are the most dangerous shape in British foraging. The tan woodland Funnel is edible, if uninspiring; the small white funnels that grow in grass include the Fool's Funnel, which contains muscarine and causes heavy sweating, drooling and stomach pain within about half an hour.

The test that decides it

Check where it grows before anything else. A tan to ochre funnel with a small central bump, in woodland leaf litter and smelling faintly of almonds, is the Funnel. Any small white funnel from grass, a lawn or a fairy ring is not - the Fool's Funnel grows exactly where people look for edible mushrooms.

The Funnel (Infundibulicybe gibba)
Photo: Ak_ccm, CC BY-SA 3.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

The Funnel

Infundibulicybe gibba

Edible with caution
  • Pinkish-buff to tan cap, never chalk white
  • A small central bump inside the funnel
  • Faint sweet smell of bitter almonds or hay
  • Leaf litter in mixed woodland, not grass

Full species guide →

Fool's Funnel (Clitocybe rivulosa)

Fool's Funnel

Clitocybe rivulosa

Poisonous
  • Small and chalk white, with a floury or silky surface
  • Grows in grass: lawns, parks, verges, often in fairy rings
  • No strong smell to warn you off
  • Contains muscarine - sweating, drooling, tears and stomach pain within about half an hour

Full species guide →

Tawny Funnel (Paralepista flaccida)

Tawny Funnel

Paralepista flaccida

Inedible
  • More orange-brown, often paler towards the edge
  • Gills darken to brownish with age
  • Grows in grass and woodland litter alike
  • Not worth eating - a reminder that not every funnel is a food find

Full species guide →

Feature by feature

FeatureThe FunnelFool's FunnelTawny Funnel
Where it growsLeaf litter in mixed woodland, hedgerows and heathsShort grass: lawns, parks, verges, fairy ringsGrass and woodland litter alike
Cap colourPinkish-buff to tan, fading in dry weatherChalk white, floury or silkyOrange-brown, often paler at the edge
Centre of the funnelA distinct small bump or umboFlat or shallowly funnelled, no bumpDepressed, no bump
GillsWhite to cream, crowded, running far down the stemWhite, crowded, later tinged greyish pinkPale at first, darkening to brown with age
SmellFaint and sweet, of bitter almonds or new-mown hayNo strong smellFaint, not almond-like
SizeCap 3-8cm on a slender stem 3-8cm tallCap 1-6cm on a stem only 3-4cm tallCap 2-8cm, stem slender

Never eat a wild mushroom on the strength of a website alone. Some deadly species look very like good edibles. Check every feature, and get an expert opinion if there is any doubt at all.

Read the full foraging safety guidance.

Common questions

Is a funnel-shaped mushroom in my lawn ever safe?
No. The Fool's Funnel grows exactly where people look for edible mushrooms - lawns, parks and verges - and it forms fairy rings just like the edible Fairy Ring Champignon. Never eat a small white funnel from grass.
Does the Funnel always have a bump in the centre?
Young caps show the small central bump most clearly, and old, fully funnelled caps can lose it. That is why habitat and colour matter as much as shape: tan and in woodland litter, not white and in grass.
What about the bigger woodland funnels?
The Trooping Funnel (Infundibulicybe geotropa) is a larger, thicker-stemmed relative of the Funnel and is edible; the Hedgehog Funnel has spines underneath instead of gills. Neither is the danger - the danger is always a small white funnel from grass.

Checked against

  • The Wildlife Hub: Fool's Funnel (Clitocybe rivulosa) - muscarine and symptoms
  • Field Mycologist and First Nature: Infundibulicybe gibba - distribution, season and checks
  • Index Fungorum / Species Fungorum current names
Share Facebook X

Other comparisons