← All lookalike guides

Slippery Jack vs Larch Bolete vs Cow Bolete

Three slimy-capped boletes grow in British conifer woods in autumn. None is dangerous, but they differ in how good they are to eat and how they should be prepared. Two checks sort them out quickly: is there a ring on the stem, and which tree is it growing under?

The test that decides it

Look at the stem and the tree. A purplish-brown ring under pine is a Slippery Jack. A ring under larch with a bright yellow-orange cap is a Larch Bolete. No ring at all, with big angular pores, is a Cow Bolete. Whichever you have, peel the slimy skin before cooking and try a small amount first.

Slippery Jack (Suillus luteus)
Photo: Tim Sage, CC BY-SA 3.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

Slippery Jack

Suillus luteus

Edible with caution
  • Chestnut to chocolate-brown, very slimy cap
  • Large, floppy ring that turns purplish-brown underneath
  • Small yellow pores
  • Only under pine
  • Edible once the slimy skin is peeled

Full species guide →

Larch Bolete (Suillus grevillei)

Larch Bolete

Suillus grevillei

Edible with caution
  • Bright yellow to orange, slimy cap
  • Whitish to yellow ring on the stem
  • Yellow pores, browning when bruised
  • Only under larch
  • Edible once the slimy skin is peeled

Full species guide →

Cow Bolete (Suillus bovinus)

Cow Bolete

Suillus bovinus

Edible with caution
  • Buff to orange-brown cap, sticky when wet
  • No ring on the stem
  • Large, angular, olive-yellow pores
  • Under pine, often on heaths
  • Rubbery and bland; edible but not highly rated

Full species guide →

Feature by feature

FeatureSlippery JackLarch BoleteCow Bolete
CapChestnut to chocolate-brown, very slimyBright yellow to orange, slimyBuff to orange-brown, sticky
RingLarge and floppy, purplish-brown underneathWhitish to yellowNone
PoresSmall, yellowSmall, yellow, bruising brownLarge and angular, olive-yellow
TreePineLarchPine
SeasonAugust to NovemberJune to NovemberAugust to November

Never eat a wild mushroom on the strength of a website alone. Some deadly species look very like good edibles. Check every feature, and get an expert opinion if there is any doubt at all.

Read the full foraging safety guidance.

Common questions

Do I have to peel Slippery Jacks?
Yes. The slimy skin causes stomach upsets in some people and makes the dish gluey. Peel it in the woods, where it comes off most easily.
Are there any deadly lookalikes?
No British bolete is known to be deadly, but the slimy-capped boletes upset some people, so try a small amount first.
Why does it matter which tree it grows under?
These boletes partner with particular trees: Slippery Jack and Cow Bolete with pine, Larch Bolete only with larch. The tree is one of the quickest clues.

Checked against

  • First Nature: Suillus luteus
  • Wild Food UK: Slippery Jack
  • Index Fungorum / Species Fungorum current names
Share Facebook X

Other comparisons