← All lookalike guides

The Miller vs Fool's Funnel vs Livid Pinkgill

The Miller is a well-loved edible that often grows near Penny Buns. Fool's Funnel is a small white mushroom that looks almost the same from above and can make you seriously ill. The Livid Pinkgill shares The Miller's pink spores and floury smell. Three checks separate them: where it grows, how the gills meet the stem, and the colour of the spore print.

The test that decides it

Take a spore print before eating anything you think is The Miller. White spores mean Fool's Funnel or another white funnel. Pink spores with gills that do not run down the stem mean a pinkgill. Only gills running down the stem, pink spores and a strong floury smell, on a mushroom growing in woodland, point to The Miller. If any check fails, leave it.

The Miller (Clitopilus prunulus)
Photo: Dr. Hans-Günter Wagner, CC BY-SA 2.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

The Miller

Clitopilus prunulus

Edible with caution
  • Soft, suede-like white to pale grey cap with a wavy edge
  • Gills run well down the stem and turn pink
  • Pink spore print
  • Strong smell of fresh flour or bread dough
  • In woodland and along woodland rides

Full species guide →

Fool's Funnel (Clitocybe rivulosa)

Fool's Funnel

Clitocybe rivulosa

Poisonous
  • Small white cap with a frosted look, often with faint rings
  • Gills run down the stem but stay white to cream
  • White spore print
  • Usually in lawns, pasture and grassy verges, often in rings
  • Poisonous: contains muscarine

Full species guide →

Livid Pinkgill (Entoloma sinuatum)
Photo: Archenzo (derivative: Ak ccm), CC BY-SA 3.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

Livid Pinkgill

Entoloma sinuatum

  • Large: cap 8-20cm, ivory to pale grey, silky
  • Gills notched, yellowish at first then pink, not running down the stem
  • Pink spore print and a mealy or rancid smell, like The Miller
  • Broadleaf woods on clay or chalk
  • Seriously poisonous

Feature by feature

FeatureThe MillerFool's FunnelLivid Pinkgill
WhereWoodland and woodland edgesGrass: lawns, pasture, vergesBroadleaf woodland
GillsRun well down the stem; turn pinkRun down the stem; stay white to creamNotched; yellowish then pink
Spore printPinkWhitePink
SmellStrong fresh flour or bread doughFaint; not a reliable clueMealy or rancid
SizeCap 3-10cmCap 2-5cmCap 8-20cm

Never eat a wild mushroom on the strength of a website alone. Some deadly species look very like good edibles. Check every feature, and get an expert opinion if there is any doubt at all.

Read the full foraging safety guidance.

Common questions

Is The Miller safe to eat?
Yes, when you are certain of it. But it has poisonous lookalikes, so take a spore print every time and ask an experienced forager to confirm your first finds.
Does The Miller really mean Penny Buns are nearby?
It is an old forager's saying and the two often grow in the same places in late summer and autumn, but it is not a rule.
What are the symptoms of Fool's Funnel poisoning?
Heavy sweating, salivation, tears, blurred vision, stomach pain and a slow heartbeat, usually within 15 to 30 minutes. Call NHS 111 or 999 and keep a sample of the mushroom.

Checked against

  • First Nature: Clitopilus prunulus
  • English Fungi: Clitopilus prunulus
  • NHS guidance on mushroom poisoning
  • Index Fungorum / Species Fungorum current names
Share Facebook X

Other comparisons