← All lookalike guides

Velvet Shank vs Funeral Bell

Velvet Shank is one of the few good edibles that keeps fruiting through frost, in clusters on dead broadleaf wood. The Funeral Bell (Galerina marginata) grows on the same kind of wood, in similar small brown clusters, and contains the same amatoxins as the Death Cap. Both can be out in November and December, sometimes on the same log.

The test that decides it

Never pick small clustered mushrooms from wood on looks alone. Velvet Shank has no ring, a dark velvety stem base and a WHITE spore print. A ring or ring zone and a RUSTY BROWN spore print means Funeral Bell. Print every cap you are unsure of, and pick each mushroom individually so a Galerina cannot slip into the basket.

Velvet Shank (Flammulina velutipes)

Velvet Shank

Flammulina velutipes

Edible
  • Shiny, sticky orange-tawny cap, often paler at the edge
  • No ring on the stem
  • Stem tough, darkening to velvety black-brown at the base
  • White spore print

Full species guide →

Funeral Bell

Galerina marginata

Deadly poisonous
  • Smaller, dull tawny cap that dries paler from the centre
  • Ring or ring zone near the top of the stem
  • Stem brownish with whitish fibres, not velvety black
  • Rusty brown spore print; contains amatoxins

Full species guide →

Feature by feature

FeatureVelvet ShankFuneral Bell
Spore printWhiteRusty brown
RingNoneRing or ring zone present
StemTough, velvety, dark brown to black at baseBrown with silky whitish fibres, not velvety
Cap surfaceGlossy and sticky when wet, orange-tawnySmooth, tawny, hygrophanous (dries paler)
GillsPale cream to yellowishOchre, becoming rusty brown
SeasonLate autumn through winter, tolerates frostMainly late summer to late autumn, overlapping into early winter

Never eat a wild mushroom on the strength of a website alone. Some deadly species look very like good edibles. Check every feature, and get an expert opinion if there is any doubt at all.

Read the full foraging safety guidance.

Common questions

Can I tell them apart without a spore print?
Experienced foragers usually can, using the ring and the velvety stem base, but the spore print is the check that removes doubt. Leave a cap on white and dark paper overnight.
How dangerous is the Funeral Bell?
Potentially fatal. Symptoms of amatoxin poisoning are often delayed 6 to 24 hours, by which time liver damage has begun. If anyone may have eaten it, go to A&E or call 111 immediately and take a sample.
Is Velvet Shank the same as supermarket enoki?
Enoki is cultivated Flammulina grown in the dark, so it looks completely different. Wild Velvet Shank is orange-capped and short-stemmed.

Checked against

  • British Mycological Society species notes
  • Index Fungorum / Species Fungorum current names
  • NHS guidance on mushroom poisoning
Share Facebook X

Other comparisons